ATHEA wants every institution and every person involved in our work to be treated fairly. If you disagree with a decision, or are unhappy with how we worked, this page explains what you can do, who deals with it, and how long it takes.

There are four routes. Choose the one that fits your situation:

Your situationRouteWho decides
Your institution disagrees with a decision of the Board of Commissioners and has new informationRequest for reconsiderationBoard of Commissioners
Your institution wants a formal review of an adverse accreditation decisionAppealBoard of Appeal for Accreditation
You are unhappy with how ATHEA, a reviewer or a member of staff behaved or followed our proceduresComplaint about ATHEAExecutive Office, then the Board of Commissioners (complaints about the Board of Commissioners or the Executive Office: Chair of the Board of Directors)
You believe an ATHEA-accredited institution does not meet our standardsComplaint about an accredited institutionBoard of Commissioners

Any other dispute between ATHEA and one of its members goes to the Arbitral Tribunal under § 16 of our Charter.

1. Request for reconsideration

If you disagree with a decision of the Board of Commissioners, you may ask it to look again.

  • Send a written request, signed by your chief executive, to appeals@athea.org within 15 days of the decision letter.
  • Explain which points of the decision you disagree with and add any new information or evidence.
  • The Board of Commissioners may invite you to present your case at its next meeting. It then confirms, changes or reverses its decision, in writing.
  • Asking for reconsideration does not take away your right to appeal.

A deferral (a decision to wait for more information or improvements) is not a final decision. You can ask for reconsideration once you have dealt with the points raised, but you cannot appeal it.

2. Appeals

What you can appeal: denial, suspension or withdrawal of accreditation.

Grounds. The decision was:

  • arbitrary, or did not follow ATHEA's principles, policies or procedures, or
  • not supported by the evidence on record.

The Board of Appeal does not judge whether ATHEA's standards are reasonable. It looks only at evidence that was in the record when the Board of Commissioners decided. Improvements made after the decision are not grounds for appeal.

How to appeal:

  1. Send a written appeal, signed by your chief executive, to appeals@athea.org within 60 days of the decision letter. State the grounds and refer to the evidence on record.
  2. The Executive Office confirms receipt within 10 working days and checks that the appeal is complete and on time.
  3. The Board of Directors appoints the Board of Appeal for Accreditation: five people with experience of ATHEA's accreditation process, at least two of them from outside ATHEA's membership. No one who took part in the review or the decision, and no one affected by the outcome, may serve.
  4. You receive written notice of the proceedings, the points at issue and the standards applied. You may be heard on all points in dispute.
  5. The Board of Appeal decides within 60 days of receiving the complete appeal. It may confirm the decision, or send it back to the Board of Commissioners with recommendations.
  6. The decision is given to you in writing, with reasons. Appeal outcomes are published on this page as a short summary, without personal data.

Your status during an appeal. Your institution keeps its accreditation status until the appeal is decided.

3. Complaints about ATHEA

You can complain about:

  • bias or a conflict of interest during a review
  • the behaviour of a reviewer, a commissioner or a member of ATHEA staff
  • a procedure that was not followed, where this does not concern the outcome of a decision (for the outcome, use reconsideration or appeal)

How it works:

  1. Write to complaints@athea.org. Say what happened, when, who was involved, and what you would like ATHEA to do. Add any evidence.
  2. The Executive Office confirms receipt within 10 working days and checks whether the matter is a complaint, an appeal or something else. It tells you which route applies.
  3. The Executive Office deals with complaints about practical matters. Complaints about reviewers or procedures go to the Board of Commissioners, which may ask a small panel with no link to the case to look into it. Complaints about the Board of Commissioners or the Executive Office go to the Chair of the Board of Directors.
  4. You receive a written answer with the findings and any action taken, within 60 days.
  5. Every complaint and its outcome is recorded and reviewed once a year as part of ATHEA's internal quality assurance.

4. Complaints about an accredited institution

Students, staff or other interested people may tell us if they believe an ATHEA-accredited institution does not meet our accreditation standards or policies.

  • Write to complaints@athea.org. Name the standards concerned and explain your relationship with the institution. Describe what happened and add documents that support your complaint.
  • If the complaint is complete, we send it to the institution's chief executive, who has 30 days to respond.
  • The Board of Commissioners reviews the complaint and the response at its next meeting. If the complaint is justified, it sets corrective actions and a timetable.
  • Both you and the institution are told the outcome in writing.

ATHEA does not deal with individual disputes between students and their institution, such as grades or fees. These should first go through the institution's own procedures.

Fair treatment

Complaints and appeals are handled confidentially. Raising a complaint or an appeal will never affect how ATHEA treats you or your institution in any review.

Documents

  • ATHEA Charter V. 4.0 (§§ 16 and 17)
  • Accreditation Process Manual (Parts Five and Seven)